Case Studies – PowerLoop – Tardivo Distillery, São Paulo (SP)
Modernization of a 1,200 kW Steam Turbine Speed Control System with the PowerLoop Controller
|
Customer |
Tardivo Distillery |
|
Equipament |
1,200 kW Steam Turbine for Power Generation |
|
Solution |
New Control Panel Featuring the PowerLoop Speed Controller |
Project Overview
|
Customer |
Tardivo Distillery |
|
Equipament |
|
|
Challenge |
PLC-based speed control with closed-source code, unstable operation, and inability to maintain stable turbine operation in island mode, disconnected from the utility grid. |
|
Solution |
Complete replacement of the control panel with a new panel featuring PowerLoop, Power-up’s proprietary speed controller. |
|
Commissioning |
Island-mode operation and load rejection tests |
|
Result |
Stable operation, including in island mode, with full customer control over the turbine control system |
The Challenge
Tardivo Distillery operates a 1,200 kW steam turbine for power generation.
The turbine's speed was controlled by a PLC running closed-source code, meaning that no user had access to modify settings or make changes to the control logic.
In practice, this situation created three major challenges for the customer:
■ Unresolved Instability: Without access to the control parameters, there was no way to adjust the system to correct turbine instability.
■ Inability to Operate in Island Mode: The turbine could not operate disconnected from the utility grid because the control system failed to function properly under these conditions.
■ Dependence on a Single Supplier: The platform was outdated, and finding qualified personnel with the expertise required to maintain it was increasingly difficult.
Why Island-Mode Operation Is So Demanding
When the turbine operates in parallel with the utility grid, the grid itself maintains the frequency at 60 Hz, while the speed governor is primarily responsible for managing the turbine load. In island mode, this external reference is no longer available. The speed governor then becomes solely responsible for maintaining stable turbine speed and, consequently, system frequency.
A common example in industrial power plants is the startup of a large electric motor, which causes a sudden increase in load. Turbine speed immediately begins to drop, and the control system must open the steam inlet valve quickly enough to restore speed before the frequency falls outside the acceptable operating range.
The opposite situation, a sudden load disconnection, requires the valve to close just as quickly to prevent turbine overspeed.
This is precisely where slow, poorly tuned, or inaccessible control systems fail.
The Solution
Destilaria Tardivo approached Power-up to resolve these issues and eliminate its dependence on a single supplier. The solution involved the complete replacement of the existing control panel with a new panel equipped with PowerLoop, Power-up's proprietary speed controller, which was already operating at another industrial facility.
The entire panel was replaced, rather than just the controller, because the existing equipment did not provide the necessary access to control parameters and was based on a significantly outdated platform.
PowerLoop Key Advantages
■ Dedicated Hardware: PowerLoop is not a PLC. It is a dedicated hardware platform developed by Power-up specifically for the operating requirements of steam turbines.
■ Processing Cycle in the 100 µs Range: A general-purpose PLC executes its program sequentially, typically with scan cycles measured in milliseconds. With a significantly shorter processing cycle, PowerLoop reads turbine speed and adjusts the control valve many more times per second, responding to load variations before turbine speed deviates from its setpoint..
■ Open Platform: The customer has full access to the controller's configuration parameters and can make adjustments without depending on the manufacturer.
■ Proven Solution: PowerLoop is already operating at another industrial facility, giving the customer confidence in its proven field performance.
Implemented Functions
■ Partida automática da turbina
■ Controle de velocidade e controle de carga
■ Modos de operação isócrono e droop
■ Sincronismo com a concessionária
■ Proteção de sobrevelocidade
Before-and-After Comparison
|
Aspect |
Previous Control System |
PowerLoop |
|
Platform |
General-purpose PLC based on an outdated platform |
PowerLoop hardware, purpose-built for steam turbine control |
|
Control System Access |
Closed-source software, with no access to configuration parameters |
Open platform with full access to all configuration parameters |
|
Processing Time |
Typical PLC scan cycle (milliseconds) |
Approximately 100 µs. |
|
Instability Correction |
Not possible without access to the configuration parameters |
Adjustable by the customer's engineering team |
|
Islanded Operation (Independent of the Utility Grid) |
Unstable operation under islanded conditions. |
Stable operation, verified during commissioning. |
|
Maintenance |
Dependence on a single supplier and limited availability of skilled technicians |
Customer independence, supported by Power-up. |
Commissioning
Commissioning was performed on-site and included the two tests that demonstrate the performance of a turbine speed governor:
■ Islanded Operation Test: The turbine operated independently of the utility grid, maintaining stable speed and frequency despite variations in plant load. This provides direct evidence that the customer's primary operational issue was successfully resolved.
■ Load Rejection Test: The generator load is suddenly removed, requiring the control system to rapidly close the steam admission valve to limit the speed increase and prevent the turbine from reaching the overspeed protection trip threshold.
Results
■ The turbine now operates reliably, including under islanded conditions, independently of the utility grid.
■ Control instability was eliminated by tuning the control loops directly through PowerLoop's open platform.
■ Tardivo Distillery now has full ownership and control of its turbine control system, without relying on a single supplier.
Key Performance Indicators
|
Indicator |
Before |
After |
|
Steady-State Speed Variation (rpm or %) |
2 - 3% |
< 0,1% |
|
Islanded Operation Frequency Variation (Hz) |
2 - 3% |
< 0,1% |
|
Parallel Operation Load Fluctuation (kW) |
250 - 350(KW) |
< 60 (KW) |
|
Load Rejection Overspeed (%) |
100% – Unable to Maintain Stability |
100% Rejected |
|
Control Functionality (%) |
70% |
100% |













